Library

Documents

42 documents

When an international court rules or a UN commission concludes an inquiry, everyone talks about it for a day. Then the document disappears, and what remains are the sentences quoted in newspapers. Here we collect the documents we cite in our pieces, with a link to the original text, so that anyone can read what they actually say.

For each document we state who wrote it, when, what it established and with what degree of certainty. Words matter. A judgment of the International Court of Justice binds the States that are parties to the case. The report of a commission of inquiry is not a judgment: it says there are “reasonable grounds to believe” that a crime has been committed, and asks a court to rule. When the accused State has responded, we report its response too.

This page grows with the site: every new piece that cites a document adds it here.

Judgments and opinions

European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber · 9 July 2025 · Russia–Ukraine

Ukraine and the Netherlands v. Russia

What it establishesRussia controlled the separatist republics from 2014 and is responsible for the downing of flight MH17, which killed 298 people. It committed systematic violations: torture, sexual violence, unlawful detention, the transfer of Ukrainian children.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding.

ResponseRussia did not take part in the proceedings and the Kremlin called the decisions “null and void”.

European Court of Human Rights · 13 March 2025 · Russia–Ukraine

Vyacheslavova and Others v. Ukraine (Odesa, 2 May 2014)

What it establishesUkraine failed to prevent the violence in Odesa, to rescue the victims of the fire in time and to investigate properly.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the respondent State.

International Court of Justice · 19 July 2024 · Israel/Palestine

Israel's policies in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (advisory opinion)

What it establishesIsrael's presence in the occupied territory is unlawful and must end as rapidly as possible. Israel must stop new settlement and evacuate the settlers. Other States must not recognise or assist this situation.

Degree of certaintyAdvisory opinion: not binding in itself, authoritative on the law.

ResponseIsrael rejected the opinion.

International Court of Justice · 26 January 2024 · Israel/Palestine

Genocide in Gaza (South Africa v. Israel), orders

What it establishesIn three orders (26 January, 28 March and 24 May 2024) the Court orders Israel to prevent acts of genocide in Gaza, to let aid in and, in May, to halt its offensive on Rafah. It has not yet decided whether genocide has been committed: the case is pending.

Degree of certaintyProvisional measures, binding; no decision on genocide.

ResponseIsrael rejects the accusation of genocide.

International Court of Justice · 16 March 2022 · Russia–Ukraine

Allegations of Genocide (Ukraine v. Russia), order

What it establishesThe Court orders Russia to suspend the military operations it began on 24 February. It says it has no evidence of the “genocide” in Donbas that Moscow had used to justify the invasion.

Degree of certaintyProvisional measure, binding; not the final judgment.

ResponseRussia has not complied with the order.

International Court of Justice · 23 January 2020 · Myanmar

Genocide of the Rohingya (The Gambia v. Myanmar)

What it establishesUnanimously, the Court orders Myanmar to prevent acts of genocide against the Rohingya and to preserve evidence. On 22 July 2022 it rejects Myanmar's objections and finds it has jurisdiction. Hearings on the merits closed in January 2026: the judgment is pending.

Degree of certaintyThe provisional measures are binding; the Court has not yet ruled on genocide.

ResponseMyanmar denies genocide.

International Court of Justice · 3 February 2015 · Balkans

Genocide in Croatia (Croatia v. Serbia)

What it establishesThe Court rejects both Croatia's claim and Serbia's counter-claim. There were killings and serious crimes on both sides, but intent to destroy a group was not proven.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the parties.

European Court of Human Rights, Grand Chamber · 13 December 2012 · United States

El-Masri v. North Macedonia

What it establishesA German citizen was arrested in Skopje, handed over to the CIA and taken to Afghanistan. The Macedonian State is responsible for torture, unlawful detention and enforced disappearance.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the respondent State.

International Court of Justice · 26 February 2007 · Balkans

Genocide in Bosnia (Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and Montenegro)

What it establishesGenocide was committed at Srebrenica in 1995. Serbia did not commit or direct it, but violated its obligation to prevent it and to hand over those responsible. When the intent to destroy a group is inferred from the facts, it must be the only reasonable inference.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the parties.

International Court of Justice · 19 December 2005 · DR Congo

Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (DR Congo v. Uganda)

What it establishesUganda violated the prohibition on the use of force by occupying Ituri, and violated human rights and humanitarian law. On 9 February 2022 the Court set reparations at 325 million dollars.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the parties.

International Court of Justice · 9 July 2004 · Israel/Palestine

The Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (advisory opinion)

What it establishesThe wall built by Israel inside the occupied territory is contrary to international law. Israel must stop building it and make reparation for the damage. The right of self-defence does not apply against a territory the State itself occupies.

Degree of certaintyAdvisory opinion: not binding in itself, authoritative on the law.

ResponseIsrael rejected the opinion.

International Court of Justice · 27 June 1986 · United States

Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v. United States)

What it establishesThe United States violated the prohibition on the use of force and on intervention by arming the contras and mining Nicaragua's ports. Supplying weapons to rebels is not an “armed attack” that would justify another State's self-defence.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the parties.

ResponseThe United States withdrew from the proceedings and did not comply with the judgment.

International Court of Justice · 9 April 1949 · General

Corfu Channel (United Kingdom v. Albania)

What it establishesAlbania is responsible for the mines in its waters that struck two British ships: it knew and gave no warning. But the United Kingdom also violated Albanian sovereignty by sweeping those waters without consent.

Degree of certaintyJudgment, binding on the parties.

International Criminal Court

International Criminal Court, Pre-Trial Chamber II · 19 March 2026 · Russia–Ukraine

Tajikistan did not arrest Putin

What it establishesTajikistan, a State party to the Court, breached its obligations by not arresting Putin during his visit in October 2025. A 2008 CIS security agreement does not override the Statute. On 7 May 2026 the matter was referred to the Assembly of States Parties.

Degree of certaintyDecision of the judges.

International Criminal Court, Trial Chamber I · 6 October 2025 · Sudan

Ali Kushayb, judgment and sentence

What it establishesThe former Janjaweed leader is guilty on 27 of 31 counts: war crimes and crimes against humanity, including murder, torture, rape and persecution, committed in West Darfur in 2003 and 2004. On 9 December 2025 he was sentenced to 20 years. It is the first conviction for Darfur.

Degree of certaintyFirst-instance judgment.

International Criminal Court, Office of the Prosecutor · 11 December 2020 · Nigeria

Nigeria, conclusion of the preliminary examination

What it establishesThere is a reasonable basis to believe that crimes against humanity and war crimes were committed both by Boko Haram and the groups that grew out of it, and by the Nigerian security forces. The request to the judges to open an investigation never came.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable basis”: the threshold for requesting an investigation.

International Criminal Court · General

The arrest warrants

The warrants for Putin, Netanyahu, the Taliban leadership, al-Bashir, Libyan commanders and the other fugitives are gathered on a dedicated page, with the up-to-date status of each.

UN inquiries

UN Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory and Israel · 14 October 2026 · Israel/Palestine

West Bank: extermination and other crimes against humanity (A/81/430)

What it establishesIsraeli authorities and forces have committed in the West Bank the crimes against humanity of extermination, torture, rape and other sexual violence, and persecution, and continue to commit acts of genocide in Gaza despite the ceasefire. Since October 2023 Israeli forces have been responsible for about 95% of the Palestinians killed in the West Bank. The report also examines the Palestinian security forces: at least 14 Palestinians killed between October 2023 and October 2025, according to the UN Human Rights Office, and arbitrary arrests, torture and ill-treatment of journalists, activists and human rights defenders, with court release orders ignored. For the Palestinian Authority the Commission finds violations of the right to life and a failure to conduct prompt and effective investigations, not international crimes.

Degree of certaintyFinding of the Commission, presented to the General Assembly. Advance version, not yet edited.

ResponseIsrael rejects the findings: the Foreign Ministry called it “a propaganda document detached from reality”. We have not found a response by the Palestinian Authority to the report.

Independent International Fact-Finding Mission on the Islamic Republic of Iran · 17 September 2026 · Iran

Iran: repression of the protests and war with the United States and Israel (A/HRC/63/61)

What it establishesIn repressing the protests that began in December 2025, the Iranian authorities committed crimes against humanity. For the war that began on 28 February 2026, there are reasonable grounds to believe that the United States committed war crimes in two strikes that killed at least 178 civilians: the Tomahawk missiles on the primary school in Minab, with more than 150 dead including about 120 children, and the strike on a sports complex and residential area in Lamerd, with 22 dead.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable grounds to believe”; a body of inquiry, not a court. The mission has never had access to Iran.

ResponseThe State Department does not consider the report credible; the Pentagon says its own investigation is still under way. The United States denies striking in the vicinity of Lamerd.

Independent International Fact-Finding Mission for the Sudan · 1 September 2026 · Sudan

Sudan: the drone war and external networks (A/HRC/63/23)

What it establishesBoth the army and the RSF use drones against hospitals, markets and civilians. The report documents the network supplying the RSF with weapons, drones, fuel and personnel, across the United Arab Emirates, Chad, Libya and Puntland.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable grounds to believe” for the network supplying the RSF; a “preliminary” inquiry into the army's suppliers, with no attribution to any State.

ResponseThe UAE denies supplying weapons to any party since April 2023.

UN Integrated Office in Haiti (BINUH) · 25 August 2026 · Haiti

Haiti: quarterly human rights report, April–June 2026

What it establishesBetween April and June 2026 at least 1,408 people were killed and 656 injured. Gang attacks caused 55% of the casualties. More than 40% of those killed and injured were documented during security force operations against gangs, sometimes involving a foreign private military company.

Degree of certaintyData documented by the mission.

UN Human Rights Monitoring Mission in Ukraine (HRMMU) · 14 July 2026 · Russia–Ukraine

Ukraine: civilian casualties in the first half of 2026

What it establishesBetween January and June 2026, 1,396 civilians were killed and 7,978 injured, 37% more than in the same period of 2025. June was the month with the most civilian deaths since April 2022. Almost all casualties were in areas controlled by the Ukrainian government, and the increase was driven mainly by Russian long-range missile and drone attacks. The Russian authorities report 250 civilians killed and 1,596 injured on their own territory: a figure the mission reports without having verified it.

Degree of certaintyData verified by the mission; the Russian figures are only reported.

UN Mission in South Sudan (UNMISS) · 30 June 2026 · South Sudan

South Sudan: violence affecting civilians, January–March 2026

What it establishesIn the first quarter of 2026 the mission documented 206 incidents of conflict-related violence: 767 civilians killed, 457 injured, 93 abducted, 71 survivors of sexual violence. Incidents fell slightly from the previous quarter, but deaths rose by 89%. The mission warns that the figures understate reality, because of limited access and resources.

Degree of certaintyData documented by the mission, declared incomplete.

UN Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory and Israel · 23 June 2026 · Israel/Palestine

“The essence of childhood has been destroyed” (A/HRC/62/CRP.2)

What it establishesIsrael deliberately targets Palestinian children, with genocide and other crimes in Gaza and war crimes in the West Bank.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable grounds to believe”.

ResponseIsrael called it a “defamatory farce” and rejects the accusation of deliberate targeting.

UN Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory and Israel · 9 June 2026 · Israel/Palestine

Killings and harm by non-State actors (A/HRC/62/22)

What it establishesHamas-affiliated forces took part in at least 60 of 249 cases of executions and severe violence in Gaza in 2024-2025, which amount to the war crimes of murder and torture. In the West Bank, settler violence is a tool of Israeli State policy, and Israel bears primary responsibility for it.

Degree of certaintyFinding of the Commission.

ResponseNeither Israel nor Hamas immediately responded to requests for comment; Israel generally denies that its soldiers shield settlers during attacks.

UN Assistance Mission in Afghanistan (UNAMA) · 12 May 2026 · Afghanistan

Afghanistan: civilian casualties of the clashes with Pakistan, January–March 2026

What it establishesIn the first three months of 2026 clashes between Taliban and Pakistani forces killed 372 civilians in Afghanistan and injured 397. Pakistani airstrikes caused 64% of the casualties. More than half of the deaths came from a single attack, the strike of 16 March on the Omid drug treatment centre in Kabul: 269 killed and 122 injured.

Degree of certaintyData verified by the mission.

ResponseIn its written response included in the report, Pakistan says no hospital, treatment centre or civilian facility was targeted, and that 130 Pakistani civilians and security personnel have been killed since the start of the year. The Taliban authorities speak of more than 400 dead in the Omid attack alone.

Independent International Fact-Finding Mission for the Sudan · 19 February 2026 · Sudan

Sudan: hallmarks of genocide in El Fasher (A/HRC/61/77)

What it establishesIn El Fasher the RSF committed at least three of the acts set out in the Genocide Convention against the Zaghawa and Fur. The violence was not random excess but a planned operation, and genocidal intent is the only reasonable inference.

Degree of certainty“Indications pointing to genocide”, on the “reasonable grounds to believe” standard; not a judgment.

ResponseThe RSF deny large-scale killings.

UN Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory and Israel · 16 September 2025 · Israel/Palestine

Legal analysis on genocide in Gaza (A/HRC/60/CRP.3)

What it establishesIsraeli authorities and forces have committed four of the five acts of genocide set out in the Convention, and genocidal intent is the only reasonable inference.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable grounds”; a body of inquiry, not a court.

ResponseIsrael rejects the finding.

Office of the UN Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict · 4 March 2024 · Israel/Palestine

Sexual violence on 7 October and against hostages (mission report)

What it establishesThere are reasonable grounds to believe that sexual violence, including rape, was committed on 7 October 2023 at several locations around Gaza, and clear and convincing information of sexual violence against some hostages. The mission received reports of sexual violence against Palestinian detainees, which it did not verify.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable grounds to believe”; “clear and convincing information”. The mission states it is not an investigation.

UN Human Rights Office · 31 August 2022 · China

Assessment of human rights concerns in Xinjiang

What it establishesThe arbitrary and discriminatory detention of Uyghurs and other Muslims may constitute international crimes, in particular crimes against humanity.

Degree of certainty“May constitute”.

ResponseChina rejects the accusations.

UN Human Rights Office and Ethiopian Human Rights Commission · 3 November 2021 · Ethiopia

Joint investigation on Tigray

What it establishesAll parties to the war committed violations, some of which may amount to war crimes and crimes against humanity. The investigation attributes unlawful killings, torture and sexual violence against civilians in Tigray to Eritrean troops.

Degree of certainty“Reasonable grounds to believe”; “may amount to”.

ResponseThe Ethiopian government welcomed it as “an important document”, with “serious reservations” on some aspects, stressing that the report finds no genocide. The TPLF rejected it, objecting to the role of the Ethiopian Commission. No known reaction from Eritrea.

Interpretations of the law

UN Human Rights Committee · 2018 · General

General Comment No. 36: the right to life

What it saysThe State must protect life also from private persons and armed groups. A death sentence after an unfair trial violates the right to life. A death in custody creates a presumption of State responsibility.

Degree of certaintyAuthoritative interpretation of the Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

UN Human Rights Office · 2016 · General

The Minnesota Protocol: investigating potentially unlawful deaths

What it saysAn investigation into a potentially unlawful death must be independent of the body involved, prompt, transparent and open to the families.

Degree of certaintyInternational reference standard.

UN Human Rights Committee · 2011 · General

General Comment No. 34: freedom of opinion and expression

What it saysProhibitions of displays of lack of respect for a religion, including blasphemy laws, are incompatible with the Covenant, except for incitement to hatred under Article 20.

Degree of certaintyAuthoritative interpretation of the Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

UN Human Rights Committee · 2007 · General

General Comment No. 32: the right to a fair trial

What it saysTrials of civilians before military courts must be the exception, justified case by case.

Degree of certaintyAuthoritative interpretation of the Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

Resolutions

Resolutions state what the body that adopts them decides: they do not establish facts.

UN Security Council · 30 September 2025 · Haiti

Haiti, the force against the gangs (resolution 2793)

UN General Assembly · 14 November 2022 · Russia–Ukraine

Reparation for Ukraine (resolution ES-11/5)

UN General Assembly · 12 October 2022 · Russia–Ukraine

The annexation of four Ukrainian regions is invalid (resolution ES-11/4)

UN General Assembly · 2 March 2022 · Russia–Ukraine

Aggression against Ukraine (resolution ES-11/1)

Demands that Russia immediately withdraw its troops from Ukraine.

UN Security Council · 26 February 2011 · Libya

Libya: referral to the ICC and arms embargo (resolution 1970)

UN Security Council · 31 March 2005 · Sudan

Darfur referred to the International Criminal Court (resolution 1593)

UN General Assembly · 14 December 1974 · General

Definition of aggression (resolution 3314)

UN General Assembly · 14 December 1962 · General

Permanent sovereignty over natural resources (resolution 1803)