
IWILLNOTLOOKAWAY.ORG
OPINION
Double standards, one law
Editorial by N3R1-70
In recent years Italy has had a great deal to decide: two wars on Europe's doorstep, the price of energy, stagnant wages, an ageing country. Parliament found the time, almost three years, for a law against antisemitism that creates no crime, increases no penalty and allocates not a single euro (our analysis).
Many people's first reaction is this: why Jews and not others? Why does someone who incites hatred against Muslims, Africans, Roma or gay people not face similar treatment?
It is a fair question, but it has to be asked properly. Asked badly, it hands those who hate Jews exactly the argument they are looking for.
What is not true
The new law gives Jews no aggravating circumstance. The aggravating circumstance for hate crimes has existed since 1993. It is Article 604-ter of the criminal code, and it applies to everyone in the same way: the penalty increases by up to half if the crime is committed "for purposes of discrimination or ethnic, national, racial or religious hatred" (art. 604-ter). Whoever beats a Jew for being Jewish, a Muslim for being Muslim, a Senegalese for being Black or a Roma person for being Roma faces the same aggravating circumstance. On this point the code is already symmetrical.
Saying that "Jews enjoy extra protection" is therefore false. And it is dangerous, because it turns a bad law into a privilege attributed to a people. That is one of the ways antisemitism grows.
What is true
The disparity exists, but it lies elsewhere. And there are two.
The first is symbolic and administrative. This law builds, for a single group, a statutory definition, a government coordinator, a national strategy, a channel in the police database and campaigns on RAI, the public broadcaster. For Roma and Sinti there is a strategy entrusted to UNAR, the office against racial discrimination, but with no statutory definition and no coordinator (UNAR, Strategy 2021-2030). For hatred against Muslims there is not even that. In this way the state says, with its own tools, that some victims count more. Not in penalties, but in attention.
The second is criminal, and concerns those left outside Article 604-ter. Italy has no specific aggravating circumstance for hatred against gay and transgender people (Domani). The same goes for people with disabilities. Some judges apply "base motives", and one court extended 604-ter to a homophobic assault (Sistema Penale), but that is the choice of an individual judge, not a rule. The law that was meant to fill the gap, the Zan bill, was stopped in the Senate on 27 October 2021 by a secret vote: 154 to 131 (Pagella Politica). In the current legislature the text has been tabled again (Senate, bill S. 22). There is still no law.
There are the double standards. The same Parliament that could not find the votes to protect someone beaten for being gay found almost three years to give the force of law to a definition the government had already been using since 2020.
The double standard is not only Italian. In the United States the president calls opposition Muslim candidates "jihadists", and accuses those who, like Abdul El-Sayed, criticise the Israeli government of hating Jews (the facts in our analysis). Hatred against one group becomes an election slogan, and the accusation of antisemitism a weapon against an opponent. That is exactly the use of the definition this law makes easier.
The strongest argument on the other side
Those who wanted this law would reply that antisemitism is not a hatred like others. It is two thousand years old, it produced the Holocaust, and in Italy it produced the racial laws of 1938, signed by the state. Synagogues are guarded by the police, and physical assaults more than doubled in a year (CDEC Report 2025). A specific historical debt, the argument goes, justifies specific tools.
The argument carries weight and must be taken seriously. But it leads to a different conclusion from the law's. A debt to people is honoured by protecting people: patrols, schools, resources, swift trials. This law allocates nothing for the security of Jewish communities. Instead, it has put at its centre a list of examples, seven of eleven devoted to the State of Israel. And fascism also persecuted and interned Roma and Sinti: that debt exists too, and nobody has thought of a law bearing its name.
Preventing, not only punishing
In almost three years of debate, little time went to the most useful question: why is antisemitism growing now? The data give a partial answer. The incidents recorded by CDEC have more than doubled since 2023, and the prevailing strand is the one linked to Israel (Avvenire). The first peak came right after 7 October, when the victims were Israeli. Then came the war in Gaza. Israel has been brought before the International Court of Justice on a charge of genocide, which it rejects (Euronews). Its defence minister said Israel was fighting "human animals" (AP), and its finance minister that letting two million civilians starve "might be justified and moral" (Eunews).
Explaining is not justifying. Whoever attacks a Jew in Rome for what a government does in Jerusalem commits a crime, and commits it twice: against a person, and against the distinction between a person and a state. But that is exactly why prevention runs through that distinction. The state should repeat, every time, that Italian Jews do not answer for the choices of the Israeli government, and that criticising that government is legitimate. The law does the opposite: it refuses to write that criticism of Israel is not antisemitism, and so it confirms the confusion on which the hatred feeds.
Who loses
Gay people, disabled people, Roma and Muslims lose: they stay where they were, that is, behind.
Freedom of criticism loses, because a definition meant to guide becomes a rule for the police, schools and universities.
And, paradoxically, Italian Jews lose. They receive neither a euro nor a new criminal protection, yet they are pointed to as the recipients of special treatment. That is the ground on which resentment grows. A law that helps antisemitism present itself as a reaction to a privilege is the opposite of a law against antisemitism.
What would be needed
Not taking something away from Jews. Giving everyone the same thing.
- An aggravating circumstance for sexual orientation, gender identity and disability. Article 604-ter can be extended, as the Zan bill proposed, or Article 61 of the criminal code can be amended, as those who opposed the Zan bill suggested (Avvenire, interview with Cesare Mirabelli). The route is open to debate; the gap is not.
- A single national strategy against hate crimes, with chapters for each targeted group, one coordinator, and the Data Protection Authority and UNAR at the table.
- Real funding for the security of places of worship of all threatened religions.
- Serious, public data collection on hate crimes, for all groups. Today the Interior Ministry itself warns that its data have no statistical value (L'Espresso).
The equality of Article 3 of the Constitution, which this law cites in its first line, is not achieved by choosing one victim at a time. It is achieved when the same attack counts the same, whoever the person attacked.
Sources: art. 604-ter · UNAR, Strategy 2021-2030 · Domani · Sistema Penale · Pagella Politica · Senate, bill S. 22 · CDEC Report 2025 · Avvenire · Euronews · AP · Eunews · Avvenire, interview with Cesare Mirabelli · L'Espresso
Related pieces: The law that defines antisemitism: what it says, what it leaves out · Credibility That Erodes — When You Criticize a Democracy Without Looking at Your Own