
IWILLNOTLOOKAWAY.ORG
ANALYSIS
Bitcoin, who controls and who taxes: the new rules in Europe and the world
7 November 2026 — European Union / United States
Series “Bitcoin, a refuge from whom?” · 3 of 4
In brief
- Since 1 July 2026 in the European Union only licensed firms may sell or hold cryptocurrencies for others, like a bank.
- Every transfer between platforms carries the name of the sender and the recipient. From 10 July 2027 platforms may no longer offer anonymous accounts or handle coins built to hide transactions.
- Keeping bitcoins in a personal wallet remains legal: the rules target intermediaries, not individuals.
- Since 2026 platforms collect customers' data for the tax authorities, which will exchange it with those of dozens of other countries. Taxes on gains, by contrast, vary from country to country: from zero to a third of the profit.
- In the United States the stablecoin law is in force; the one on the rest of the market has stalled in the Senate.
For its first ten years Bitcoin lived in a grey zone. The platforms where it was bought and sold opened and closed without a licence, many users did not know whether or how much tax they owed, and tax authorities across half the world had no way of knowing who owned what. In Europe, that grey zone closed in 2026.
In the first part we saw that on the Bitcoin network no one can freeze a payment, and that states therefore act "at the entrances and exits", that is, on the platforms. This third part explains how they do it: who may sell cryptocurrencies, who must know who you are, what the tax authorities know and how much you pay. As in the other parts, we set it against gold and everyday money. We focus on the rules of the European Union and international ones, because they apply in many countries at once; on taxes, each country goes its own way.
1. Who may sell and hold them
Bitcoin. Since 30 December 2024 the European Union has applied MiCA, the regulation on markets in crypto-assets: anyone who buys, sells, exchanges or holds cryptocurrencies on behalf of others must be authorised, like a bank or an investment firm. Platforms already operating under national rules had a transition period, which ended for all on 1 July 2026. Since that day those without a licence can no longer serve European customers. The European markets authority, ESMA, asked unauthorised platforms to wind down in an orderly way, and savers to move their funds to an authorised platform or to a wallet of their own.
Gold. Buying and selling investment gold has long been a regulated activity: dealers are subject to anti-money-laundering rules and, in many countries, must be listed in special registers.
Money. Taking deposits requires a banking licence, and banks have been supervised by central banks for more than a century. MiCA, in essence, brings cryptocurrency platforms inside the same fence.
2. Who must know who you are
Bitcoin. Since 30 December 2024 the so-called travel rule has applied to cryptocurrencies too: every transfer between two platforms must carry with it the name of the sender and of the recipient, for any amount. If the transfer goes to or comes from a personal wallet, the platform must check, above 1,000 euros, that the wallet really belongs to the customer. From 10 July 2027, under the new European anti-money-laundering regulation, platforms may no longer offer anonymous accounts or handle so-called privacy coins, cryptocurrencies built to hide transactions, such as Monero and Zcash. Privacy advocates argue that this violates the right to privacy protected by the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. The ban, however, does not concern cryptocurrencies alone: the same regulation also bans anonymous accounts at banks.
One clarification is needed, because many false rumours circulate online: keeping your own bitcoins in a personal wallet remains legal. The rules target platforms, not individuals who hold their own keys, and direct transfers between two personal wallets remain outside the travel rule.
Gold. A bar bought in a shop, above a certain threshold, requires ID. Then, locked away at home, it leaves no trace.
Money. A bank transfer always carries the name of the payer and the payee: the travel rule was born there, for banks, and has been extended to cryptocurrencies. Cash remains anonymous, but from 10 July 2027, throughout the Union, it will not be possible to pay a business more than 10,000 euros in cash.
3. What the tax authorities know
Bitcoin. Since 1 January 2026 platforms serving European customers must collect their users' tax data and record purchases, sales and transfers. This is required by the European DAC8 directive. In 2027 they will send the 2026 data to the tax authority of their own country, which will pass it on to that of the country where the customer lives. Those who do not provide their data may, after two reminders, have their transactions blocked. DAC8 applies in Europe an OECD standard, the Crypto-Asset Reporting Framework, which by June 2026 76 countries had joined: 46 will start exchanging data in 2027, others in 2028, the United States in 2029. In the United States, meanwhile, platforms already report customers' sales to the tax authority: the first form, the 1099-DA, covers transactions from 2025.
Gold. For gold kept at home or in a safe-deposit box there is no automatic exchange of information between states. A gold account at a bank, however, depending on how it is set up, may fall within the reporting on financial accounts.
Money. For bank accounts an automatic exchange has existed since 2017: it is called the Common Reporting Standard, the OECD created it after the 2008 crisis to fight capital hidden abroad, and today more than a hundred countries apply it. The cryptocurrency standard is, in effect, its copy.
4. How much you pay
Bitcoin. Here the European Union has no common rules: each country decides for itself, and the differences are huge. In Germany those who hold bitcoins for more than a year and then sell them pay nothing; in Portugal a similar rule applies, while sales within the year pay 28%; in France the gain pays 31.4% (it was 30% until 2025); in Italy, since 2026, 33%. The same sale, with the same gain, can cost from nothing to a third of the profit depending on where you live.
Then there is a detail that surprises many. In many countries paying for something in bitcoin, a coffee or a car, counts as selling bitcoin: if the price has risen since you bought it, that payment produces a gain to be declared. It is one of the reasons few people use Bitcoin for their shopping.
On VAT, by contrast, a common rule does exist. In 2015 the Court of Justice of the European Union, in the case of a Swede who wanted to open an exchange service, ruled that exchanging euros for bitcoin and vice versa is exempt from VAT, like exchanging currencies.
Gold. Investment gold is also exempt from VAT throughout the Union, under a European rule. The gain on a sale, as with Bitcoin, is taxed in different ways from country to country.
Money. Interest on an account or a government bond is taxed everywhere, but no one pays tax for spending a euro. For the tax authorities, Bitcoin looks more like an investment than like money.
5. And the United States?
The United States has moved in another direction. In July 2025 it passed the GENIUS Act, the first federal law on stablecoins, which requires issuers to hold reserves and to be able to freeze funds on the authorities' orders. The broader law, the CLARITY Act, which is meant to establish who supervises the rest of the market, passed the House in July 2025 but stalled in the Senate: on 15 September 2026 it failed to get the 60 votes needed to be debated on the floor, and it is unlikely to return before 2027. Meanwhile Washington has created the Strategic Bitcoin Reserve. In short, the country in whose currency almost all stablecoins are denominated regulated those first.
6. Where the rules do not reach
All these rules have one thing in common: they target intermediaries. Platforms, banks, dealers. Those who keep bitcoins in their own wallet and exchange them directly with another person remain outside automatic controls, like those who keep gold under the mattress or pay each other in cash.
Outside the controls, however, does not mean outside the law. The gain must be declared anyway, and sooner or later, to convert bitcoins into euros and pay the rent, almost everyone goes through a platform, that is, through a door that now records who comes in and who goes out. The freedom Bitcoin promises remains intact on the network. At the entrances and exits, by now, it gets the same treatment as money.
The mirror
| Bitcoin | Gold | Money | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who may sell or hold it | only authorised platforms (EU, since 1 July 2026) | regulated dealers | only licensed banks |
| Name of payer and payee | mandatory between platforms; check above €1,000 with a personal wallet | ID above a threshold, then no trace | mandatory in transfers; cash limited from 2027 |
| Does the tax office know? | since 2026, through the platforms (EU and dozens of other countries) | it depends: a gold account may be covered, gold at home is not | yes, since 2017, for accounts abroad |
| VAT | exempt (EU Court of Justice, 2015) | exempt (investment gold) | does not apply |
| Tax on gains | different in every country: from zero to a third | different in every country | interest is taxed, not spending |
| Outside the controls | personal wallet and private exchanges | gold kept at home | cash between individuals |
What changes
For seventeen years Bitcoin was presented as the money that escapes states. In Europe, since 2026, anyone using a platform is treated more or less like anyone using a bank: licence, ID, data for the tax authorities. Only those who give up intermediaries and take on themselves the burden, and the risk, of keeping their own keys remain free.
Is it a step towards normality or an attempt to tame a system born to do without it? Institutions say they want to stop money laundering and tax evasion, with the same rules that already apply to money. Bitcoin supporters reply that every new control makes the original promise less true. On this question the site takes a position in a separate Opinion, signed.
This article describes the rules; it is not tax or investment advice: rules change from country to country and over time.
Sources: MiCA · asked · travel rule · the new European anti-money-laundering regulation · argue · the European DAC8 directive · 76 countries had joined · the 1099-DA · Common Reporting Standard · pay nothing · pay 28% · 31.4% · 33% · paying for something in bitcoin · the Court of Justice of the European Union · a European rule · failed to get the 60 votes
Related pieces: Bitcoin in the mirror: how it works, compared with gold and with money · Bitcoin, who freezes and who flees: Russia's reserves, sanctions and the Hormuz toll · The keys